My Thoughts
The Government Should Consider 5 Critical Policies for Senior Citizens
The Perikatan Nasional (PN) government’s policy on comprehensively protecting the wellbeing of senior citizens is clearly outdated and insensitive to the needs of senior citizens and the threats they face during the Covid-19 pandemic.
Malaysia is expected to become an aged nation by 2030, with 15% of the population aged 60 and above (Department of Statistics Malaysia figures). The Ministry of Women, Family and Community Development (KPWKM) Strategic Plan 2021–2025, recently announced by the KPWKM Minister, is therefore critical in preparing the country to become an aged nation.
The government needs to create a professional ecosystem in the healthcare and social welfare services industry for senior citizens, taking into account the changing needs of seniors affected by the Covid-19 pandemic.
According to several international studies conducted after Covid-19 swept the world, developing a home care model for senior citizens has become an increasingly popular option for the future compared with group care centres. Sadly, the sharp rise in deaths among elderly residents of care centres due to Covid-19 has exposed their weakness: they easily become incubators for the virus.
Factors that make elderly residents more vulnerable to the virus include a shortage of caregivers, a shortage of professional health staff and a lack of basic personal protective equipment due to financial constraints at care centres; physical distancing that cannot be practised because of cramped space; the absence of registered nurses (RNs) to set up and monitor procedures for handling outbreaks at the centres; and several other contributing factors.
There are therefore 5 policies that the government should consider. First, upgrade the physical facilities and the professional health and social workforce at elderly care centres so that they can cope with the threat of viral infections such as Covid-19.
Policy on elderly care centres must now include professional healthcare, by placing at least one registered nurse (RN) at each centre to be responsible for medical matters and any emergencies that may arise among residents.
In addition, according to the World Health Organization (WHO) 2015 publication “Home Health Care for the Elderly”, home healthcare is the main option that allows senior citizens to live independently in their own homes and age in the community. Independence has become the “keyword” for positive and active ageing, and it is also more cost-effective. However, coordinating services and keeping them consistent is more challenging than in the care centre model.
In fact, developing a home-based healthcare and social support service model for senior citizens enables seniors to remain independent for as long as possible and delays them becoming dependent on other family members or society.
Second, it is time for KPWKM to study how to upgrade the Home Help Service Programme (Program Khidmat Bantu di Rumah), implemented since 2012, into a more holistic and comprehensive programme. This home service package should include professional home healthcare and social support services, rather than relying on volunteers alone.
According to Budget 2021, the programme’s capacity is only 8,000 elderly clients nationwide, compared with 3.5 million senior citizens in Malaysia. To date, there is no strategy in this 5-year Strategic Plan showing any intention by the government to improve the model or increase the capacity of the Home Help Service Programme.
Third, to develop a holistic elderly care service ecosystem, the government needs a plan to produce more professional, quality workers. KPWKM policy must therefore raise the skill qualifications of the workforce in the public and private elderly care services sector to guarantee the quality of service.
Although one of the strategies in the KPWKM Strategic Plan (page 78) includes making social work a professional service, it focuses only on human capital development within ministries and government agencies. The government must understand that professional social workers are needed in every sector, not only in the public sector or in elderly care services.
For example, the education or skill qualifications for the post of Supervisor of a Senior Citizens Activity Centre (PAWE) should be raised in phases over 5 years, from Sijil Pelajaran Malaysia (SPM) holders to holders of the Malaysian Skills Certificate or Diploma (SKM) in elderly care services, or to social work degree holders.
Fourth, reform welfare institutions so that public welfare institutions focus more on setting, auditing and formulating policies and regulations, shaping community programmes according to objectives, and strengthening the welfare services industry for target groups by providing grants, even if they are not directly involved in delivering services to those groups.
A professional workforce is critical to support the reform of welfare institutions in the country. The way KPWKM works with non-governmental organisations (NGOs), foundations, corporations and others through its departments and boards must be reviewed.
Ministries and departments must strengthen the government’s role as the administrator, maker and implementer of policies, systems and regulations, focusing on auditing the performance of social service delivery programmes run through agencies and non-governmental social welfare organisations. This can reduce the risk of procurement leakages, misappropriation and abuse of power in government organisations.
This would create competition among non-governmental social welfare organisations, as agents delivering social services and support, for government grants. As these organisations develop, demand for professional workers such as social workers will rise and the quality of services will improve. I hope this proposal to reform welfare institutions can be studied and considered under the restructuring of KPWKM and its agencies in the Strategic Plan 2021–2025 (page 74).
Policies to address ageing should not be “one size fits all”, but should be tailored to the needs of older and the oldest senior citizens. According to the Department of Statistics Malaysia, senior citizens aged 60–64 numbered 1.2 million (3.7%), while those aged 65 and above numbered 2.3 million (7%) of the total population in 2020.
As Covid-19 vaccination registration showed, senior citizens are not only less familiar with digital applications; some are older, with declining abilities overall, and badly need extra help from family members or the community to carry out such personal tasks.
Therefore, with reference to the 5-year Strategic Plan (page 42), although it is filled with visions of digitalising senior citizens’ data, such as developing the National Senior Citizens Registration System (e-WEN), who will help our older patti and thatha, ah gong and ah ma, nenek and atuk to register if the government wants to preserve senior citizens’ independent lifestyles?
Fifth, KPWKM should consider providing a hotline as a basic facility for senior citizens to access information on welfare for the elderly. The hotline should also offer several language options so that language does not become a barrier for senior citizens in exercising their rights.
The right to enjoy old age with dignity is a basic right of every citizen, and the government must take seriously all the impacts and changes in the elderly care services sector, especially since the outbreak of Covid-19.