My Thoughts
Muhyiddin’s Neglect of the Local Beef Industry Is Why Beef Is So Expensive
1. I refer to Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin’s promise on 23 April that the government would be proactive in tackling rising prices of essential goods that burden low-income groups, through continuous monitoring and enforcement.
2. The Muhyiddin government should in fact deal comprehensively with the rising prices of essentials, especially beef, a main dish during the festive seasons of Hari Raya Aidilfitri and Hari Raya Aidiladha.
3. According to the 2019 Market Review of the Food Sector by the Malaysia Competition Commission (MyCC), Malaysia’s beef self-sufficiency ratio (SSR) in 2018 was low (22%) because of insufficient local beef production. As a result, Malaysia has to meet domestic demand for beef from limited import sources.
4. The Muhyiddin government’s sincerity is highly doubtful if we look at page 13 of MAFI’s 2021 Budget Report, where Code 22500 (Beef Cattle Project) shows the government spent only RM100 of the remaining project cost of RM8,134,000 in 2020. This proves the project was abandoned in 2020.
5. The government should have no more excuses to delay reforms in the ruminant sector.
6. I urge the Muhyiddin government to take up the recommendation of the Malaysia Competition Commission (MyCC) in the same report: break up the oligopoly among beef exporters by increasing the number of qualified slaughterhouses, boosting competition among operators while guaranteeing meat quality.
7. At the same time, the Muhyiddin government should revive idle or under-used government livestock land and departmental facilities to reduce dependence on imports. For example, the government has thousands of acres at the Kluang Modern Agriculture Project (PPM) and the Permanent Food Production Parks (TKPM) nationwide that are not yet being used to their full potential.
8. To encourage the local ruminant livestock industry, the government can also work with state governments and utility providers to offer land such as TNB wayleave reserves, reserve land along gas pipeline routes and JPS riverside reserves for growing animal feed crops (napier grass or maize).
9. Finally, I urge the Muhyiddin government to carry out the ruminant sector reforms proposed above.