Articles

Pakatan Harapan Regroups in Opposition: What Kind of Reform Do You Want?

After 509, how should Pakatan Harapan, an opposition that once governed at the federal level, renew itself as an opposition tempered by the experience of governing?

a) Be a responsible opposition that does not merely criticise government policy but also proposes more practical solutions, positioning Pakatan Harapan as a “government in waiting”.

b) In a democracy, the opposition does not exist to threaten the ruling party as a rival forever trying to seize power, but as a competitor that debates governing philosophy and policy with the ruling party, and together leads the country towards a better future.

c) Form a shadow cabinet, bring back the political operatives who served as political appointees in government, provide resources and build a complete team to push and monitor the ruling party, and even begin drafting a governing direction for the country in the post-Covid new normal, a Buku Harapan 2.0.

“Pakatan Harapan Regroups in Opposition: What Kind of Reform Do You Want?”

I was honoured to be invited as one of the panellists that evening. After the programme, I reorganised what I shared and added a few points. I will begin with the role of the opposition, then share the experience of Pakatan Harapan’s 22 months in Putrajaya, before discussing the reforms I would like to see. In exploring how the opposition, or Pakatan Harapan, should change, I believe reform can mean breaking old patterns of thinking or ideology, as well as real change to existing systems and institutions.

For Pakatan Harapan, which holds the most seats in the opposition and suddenly lost power this time, how should it transform into a different kind of opposition? What should be different? How should it be different? Let us take 509 as the dividing line and discuss the role of the opposition before 509, and of Pakatan Harapan after 509, having once governed at the federal level.

The role and performance of Pakatan Harapan as the opposition before 509:

a) Too many political gimmicks

b) Opposing policies for the sake of opposing, without being able to offer proposals

c) Playing a role of checks and balances and questioning the government

d) More time spent finding faults and issues of wrongdoing.

In my view, Pakatan Harapan’s performance before 509 was the result of a federal government that had not changed for 61 years. Pakatan Harapan before 509 inherited these natural weaknesses: no experience of governing at the federal level, a limited understanding of how the central government operates, and limited information. This includes how laws passed in Parliament or Cabinet decisions are implemented from the top down through government agencies and non-governmental organisations. Most importantly, how to anticipate the impact of each policy once implemented, and how far its reach would extend.

After 509, what did we learn during Pakatan Harapan’s 22 months in federal government? (What I share here represents only my personal observations and experience):

a) A first encounter with a vast bureaucracy: Putrajaya is the country’s highest centre of decision-making, and we had to understand how it operates. For example, the Ministry of Agriculture has 4 major divisions and 9 agencies, most with branch offices in every state.

b) Dealing with office politics

c) Understanding the challenges and obstacles to implementing new policies first, before being able to propose, approve or implement them

d) Understanding the hardships of civil servants who face difficulty implementing policies

e) Understanding how each sector and industry is linked to the whole system, and so on.

So, after 509, how should Pakatan Harapan, an opposition that once governed at the federal level, renew itself as an opposition tempered by the experience of governing?

a) Be a responsible opposition that does not merely criticise government policy but also proposes more practical solutions, positioning Pakatan Harapan as a “government in waiting”.

b) In a democracy, the opposition does not exist to threaten the ruling party as a rival forever trying to seize power, but as a competitor that debates governing philosophy and policy with the ruling party, and together leads the country towards a better future.

c) Form a shadow cabinet, bring back the political operatives who served as political appointees in government, provide resources and build a complete team to push and monitor the ruling party, and even begin drafting a governing direction for the country in the post-Covid new normal, a Buku Harapan 2.0.

In conclusion, besides absorbing the experience of being in government and refocusing on its role as the opposition, Pakatan Harapan must also present itself as a “government in waiting”, show the renewed face of Pakatan Harapan, seek a fresh mandate from the people, win back their confidence and pave the way for the next election. In truth, I am full of hope for Pakatan Harapan. Compared with before, today’s Pakatan Harapan is far more capable of governing the country and can do better.

The second thing I wish to share is my hope that Pakatan Harapan, in drafting its next Buku Harapan, can break some of the old ideologies in society. Unfortunately, I could not fully elaborate on this at Saturday’s programme; I will discuss it separately in another piece of writing.